by Riestal » Sun Mar 18, 2012 6:52 am
Well, lets look at your team before I tell you what I would do. The key to team composition is balance. I would want sweepers, walls, and stallbreakers to make a Fighting Type team survive some of it's biggest weaknesses, so lets see what you've got going. Personally, I would keep Mienshao. If Mienshao has Regenerator, U-Turn Life Orb makes it an amazing threat, and it actually has a pretty versatile movepool, you can get lots of coverage off of it. Breloom and Toxicroak are bulkier, and they can use status like Spore and Toxic to wear down on your opponent. I say keep them both. Scrafty is incredibly bulky, and if done right, he can easily wall out your opponent while you drain them with toxic, or Bulk Up to sweep, even. A lot of people don't like him for his design, but he's an incredible Pokemon. Lucario and Infernape, also, are two of my favorite Pokemon of all time, and each of them make amazing mixed sweepers. Infernape with Overheat and U-Turn makes for a great hit and run Pokemon, and Lucario can just fill his movepool with a pantload of super effective moves. You've got a pretty good thing going there, it's now all about how you build it.
As for me personally? I tend to always opt not to use Legendary status Pokemon, so none of the Musketeers appeal to me for Competitive battling. My team would probably be Infernape, Mienshao, Scrafty, Breloom, Hitmonlee, and Heracross, and I would have a Lucario, Toxicroak, Gallade, and Machamp trained just in case I wanted to trade some guys out later. The main reason I would replace Lucario and Toxicroak is that Toxic doesn't appeal to me all that much on a fighting team. I feel like, if you have to drain a pokemon with poison, it means you can't just punch through it, and I'd MUCH RATHER punch through it! And, since Infernape does what Lucario does, just with U-Turn to avoid threatening Psychic types, I feel that another mixed sweeper would be redundant. Heracross is a bug, so I hit Psychics HARD with Megahorn (seriously, don't underestimate the glory that is Heracross), and the Hitmonlee I used at PAX East 2011 had Blaze Kick, Earthquake, Close Combat, and SUCKER PUNCH. That's all totally legal. So, Hitmonlee covers a bunch more damage than Lucario could with his brutal powerful manytype moves, and he also one shots any Psychic that would dream of attacking me.
All in all, I think you have a good thing going. Give the guys you have a good set of moves, items, and abilities, make them work well together, and you'll be all set!